Dear all, We are thinking of purchasing a development environment like WebGain Studio for our project. Which do you think is the best environment to develop & debug JSP/JavaBeans & EJBs for WebLogic server? Is purchasing such an environment going to improve our productivity significantly, or do you believe we are going to be fine with a text editor, JDK 1.3 & J2EE 1.2.1? What do you think about the BDK from sun? I am looking forward to hearing from you. Cheers, Mike
I should coco (I've been evaluating WebGain Studio for two months now). If you're looking at comparing the a text editor and the SDK with WebGain Studio I think you'll find that WebGain Studio will be much more productive. An IDE which includes features such as StructureBuilder (tying your UML to your build) and integrated debugging of EJBs using WebLogic from within Cafe will make things much easier than labouring with a text editor. It cuts out much of the EJB/Servlet legwork and offers real advantages by integrating Dreamweaver and JSP tags with servlet development in the IDE. Text editors are fine but if you're trying to meet deadlines and bump up your productivity, the IDE will offer you some real time savings. Not sure about the BDK, I've never had to use it. My comparisons have been with primarily IBM's Visual Age for Java; if you're using the IDE with integration of BEA's WebLogic products in mind, IMHO WebGain is the winner.
posted 18 years ago
George, thanks a lot for your reply. I am actually trying to decide which of WebGain Studio, IBM VisualAge, JBuilder and CodeWarrior is the best for building our solution on WebLogic Server. After reading some reviews on the above products I came to the conclusion that WebGain and JBuilder are the best for what we need to do. I fully agree with what you say about productivity and meeting deadlines, so the only issue we have is to make the right choice. I have compiled the following list of pros and cons: WebGain Studio. Pros. Good Database connectivity Uses Wizards Bundled with Dreamweaver Integrates with 3rd party configuration management tool. Provides EJB functionality Cons. Cost Wizards provide inefficient code Reports suggest it can be flaky. Borland JBuilder Pro. Pros Cheaper than WebGain Good functionality Stability Good cross platform support Cons. Possible heavy system requirements (512Mb RAM Dual Processor - PC, not server !) No EJB support Cannot integrate with 3rd party config management tool. Do you or anyone else have any comment on that? Any more info (bad/good experiences) for any of these products will be very much appreciated. Kind Regards, Mike
Michael: I am using JBuilder3.5 for about two month for a web project. The system requirement is not that heavy as you mentioned. My developing station only has 128 RAM, so far it is performing well. However, the servlet support is not current in JBuilder version 3.5 because I am working on customerize jsp tags, and it does not support it. My solution is link it with tomcat. But you will have WebLogic, so I think that would not be a problem for u.
I'm sure JBuilder with a bundled Tomcat server is a convenient solution, but bear in mind that there is nothing stopping anyone from running their own web/servlet/EJB server with any IDE. I use a combination of Kawa and Resin for my local development which gives me similar benefits.
Thanks a lot guys. Your comments were greatly appreciated. I think that we are going for the WebGain solution because of its very good debugger, good integration with WebLogic and the support for third-party source control utility like pvcs (which we have already bought). I was very tempted though with JBuilder 4 EE and if it was my choice only then I would probably go for that. Kinds Regards, Michael
just let me add something how bout forte. iternet edition beta is out and flawless from what i made with it. the system requirements are not as high as they say.i have a 233 mhz 96 mb of memory and a 192 mb swap file that is optimized for performance. it just takes a few mins to load. ------------------ I wish there was a button on my monitor to turn up the intellegince. Theres a button called 'brightness' but it doesn't work
"Programming today is a race between software engineers striving to build bigger and better idiot-proof programs, and the Universe trying to produce bigger and better idiots. So far, the Universe is winning."