Arjun Shastry

Ranch Hand

Posts: 1903

1

posted 13 years ago

This was asked during one test:

Two friends A and B are playing with two dices. One dice has 5 red faces and one blue.They define the game:"If same color appears on top faces of dices ,A wins else B wins."Probability of winning of each is same(1/2).

How many faces of second dice are blue/red?

[hint: requires basic probability]

Two friends A and B are playing with two dices. One dice has 5 red faces and one blue.They define the game:"If same color appears on top faces of dices ,A wins else B wins."Probability of winning of each is same(1/2).

How many faces of second dice are blue/red?

[hint: requires basic probability]

MH

Roy Tock

Ranch Hand

Posts: 83

posted 13 years ago

Interesting...the answer is 3/3. I wouldn't have expected that!

Let R be the number of red faces on the second die. The probability of rolling two reds, then, is 5R/36. The probability of rolling two blues is 1(6-R)/36. We know the sum of the two probabilites must be 1/2, so

5R/36 + (6-R)/36 = 1/2

=> 5R + (6-R) = 18

=> 4R + 6 = 18

=> 4R = 12

=> R = 3. QED

Let R be the number of red faces on the second die. The probability of rolling two reds, then, is 5R/36. The probability of rolling two blues is 1(6-R)/36. We know the sum of the two probabilites must be 1/2, so

5R/36 + (6-R)/36 = 1/2

=> 5R + (6-R) = 18

=> 4R + 6 = 18

=> 4R = 12

=> R = 3. QED

Jim Yingst

Wanderer

Sheriff

Sheriff

Posts: 18671

Arjun Shastry

Ranch Hand

Posts: 1903

1

posted 13 years ago

Perfect

Originally posted by Roy Tock:

Interesting...the answer is 3/3. I wouldn't have expected that!

Let R be the number of red faces on the second die. The probability of rolling two reds, then, is 5R/36. The probability of rolling two blues is 1(6-R)/36. We know the sum of the two probabilites must be 1/2, so

5R/36 + (6-R)/36 = 1/2

=> 5R + (6-R) = 18

=> 4R + 6 = 18

=> 4R = 12

=> R = 3. QED

Perfect

MH

Roy Tock

Ranch Hand

Posts: 83

posted 13 years ago

OK, let's generalize.

Say you have two D-sided dice. On the first, S sides are red and (D-S) sides are blue. How many red sides must there be on die 2 for the win probability to be the same for both players?

Again, let R be the number of red faces on die 2. The probability of rolling two reds is S/D * R/D = RS/DD. The probability of rolling two blues is (D-S)/D * (D-R)/D = (DD-SD-RD+RS)/DD. So since the probability of a win for either is 1/2,

RS/DD + (DD-SD-RD+RS)/DD = 1/2

=> RS + DD - SD - RD + RS = DD/2

=> 2RS - RD = DD/2 - DD + SD

=> R(2S-D) = SD - DD/2

=> R(2S-D) = D(S-D/2)

=> R(2S-D) = (D/2)(2S-D)

=> R = D/2. (assuming 2S!=D)

If 2S=D, again we find R = D/2 (proof left up to the reader).

So... Regardless of how many sides are red and blue on die 1, the probability of a win for either is 1/2 if D is even and, on die 2, half the sides are red and half blue.

It makes sense; think of it this way. As long as D is even, it doesn't matter what's rolled on die 1 if die 2 is colored half and half. If die 1 is red, odds are 50/50 that die 2 will be red. If die 1 is blue, odds are 50/50 that die 2 will be blue.

So the result is independent of the number of red sides on die 1. It could be 0, D, or anywhere in between. As long as D is even, the result holds.

Further, if D is odd, there is no correct painting of die 2.

[ July 22, 2003: Message edited by: Roy Tock ]

Say you have two D-sided dice. On the first, S sides are red and (D-S) sides are blue. How many red sides must there be on die 2 for the win probability to be the same for both players?

Again, let R be the number of red faces on die 2. The probability of rolling two reds is S/D * R/D = RS/DD. The probability of rolling two blues is (D-S)/D * (D-R)/D = (DD-SD-RD+RS)/DD. So since the probability of a win for either is 1/2,

RS/DD + (DD-SD-RD+RS)/DD = 1/2

=> RS + DD - SD - RD + RS = DD/2

=> 2RS - RD = DD/2 - DD + SD

=> R(2S-D) = SD - DD/2

=> R(2S-D) = D(S-D/2)

=> R(2S-D) = (D/2)(2S-D)

=> R = D/2. (assuming 2S!=D)

If 2S=D, again we find R = D/2 (proof left up to the reader).

So... Regardless of how many sides are red and blue on die 1, the probability of a win for either is 1/2 if D is even and, on die 2, half the sides are red and half blue.

It makes sense; think of it this way. As long as D is even, it doesn't matter what's rolled on die 1 if die 2 is colored half and half. If die 1 is red, odds are 50/50 that die 2 will be red. If die 1 is blue, odds are 50/50 that die 2 will be blue.

So the result is independent of the number of red sides on die 1. It could be 0, D, or anywhere in between. As long as D is even, the result holds.

Further, if D is odd, there is no correct painting of die 2.

[ July 22, 2003: Message edited by: Roy Tock ]

Jim Yingst

Wanderer

Sheriff

Sheriff

Posts: 18671

posted 13 years ago

Aww, I was hoping to get to to do more detailed math on that one. Then follow up with something like a 100-sided die with 29 red and 71 blue.

Indeed, the details of the first die are irrelevant - all we really need to know is that there are only two possible outcomes for the first die, red or blue. Then we can always get a 50% chance of a match using a second die which has a 50% chance of either color. It's like if you have an exam with true/false questions - you've got a 50% chance of answering correctly if you just flip a coin.

Indeed, the details of the first die are irrelevant - all we really need to know is that there are only two possible outcomes for the first die, red or blue. Then we can always get a 50% chance of a match using a second die which has a 50% chance of either color. It's like if you have an exam with true/false questions - you've got a 50% chance of answering correctly if you just flip a coin.

"I'm not back." - Bill Harding, *Twister*

Arjun Shastry

Ranch Hand

Posts: 1903

1

posted 13 years ago

Will the result be same even if second dice is biased?I think combination of colors on second dice should be irrelevant.

MH

Joe Pluta

Ranch Hand

Posts: 1376

posted 13 years ago

It's too late for me to work this out in my head, so I'll post it as a thought exercise: how does the math work if the FIRST die is 50/50? Since the answer should be that ANY combination on the second die works, I'd be interested to see what happens with the math.

Just wondering, before I wander off into snoozeland.

Joe

Just wondering, before I wander off into snoozeland.

Joe

Bhau Mhatre

Ranch Hand

Posts: 199

posted 13 years ago

Look at Roy's equation:

RS/DD + (DD-SD-RD+RS)/DD = 1/2

=> RS + DD - SD - RD + RS = DD/2

=> 2RS - RD = DD/2 - DD + SD

=> R(2S-D) = SD - DD/2

=> R(2S-D) = D(S-D/2)

=> R(2S-D) = (D/2)(2S-D)

=> R = D/2. (assuming 2S!=D)

If 2S=D, again we find R = D/2 (proof left up to the reader).

If 2S=D, then R need not be D/2 as he said. It can be anything and its value will be irrelavant.

Originally posted by Joe Pluta:

how does the math work if the FIRST die is 50/50? Since the answer should be that ANY combination on the second die works, I'd be interested to see what happens with the math.

Look at Roy's equation:

RS/DD + (DD-SD-RD+RS)/DD = 1/2

=> RS + DD - SD - RD + RS = DD/2

=> 2RS - RD = DD/2 - DD + SD

=> R(2S-D) = SD - DD/2

=> R(2S-D) = D(S-D/2)

=> R(2S-D) = (D/2)(2S-D)

=> R = D/2. (assuming 2S!=D)

If 2S=D, again we find R = D/2 (proof left up to the reader).

If 2S=D, then R need not be D/2 as he said. It can be anything and its value will be irrelavant.

-Mumbai cha Bhau

Joe Pluta

Ranch Hand

Posts: 1376

posted 13 years ago

Here's why (paraphrasing the original calcs):

Say you have two D-sided dice. On the first, D/2 sides are red and D/2 sides are blue. How many red sides must there be on die 2 for the win probability to be the same for both players?

Let R be the number of red faces on die 2. The probability of rolling two reds is (D/2)/D * R/D = R/2D. The probability of rolling two blues is (D/2)/D * (D-R)/D = (D-R)/2D. So since the probability of a win for either is 1/2,

R/2D + (D-R)/2D = 1/2

=> R + D - R = D

=> D = D

R factors out, so all values of R are correct!

And what this says is that if either die is 50/50, then no matter the configuration of the second die (provided it has only faces of either red or blue), the chances are 50/50 of getting two of the same color.

This is certainly not intuitive at first glance, but is very cool!

Joe

Originally posted by Mumbai cha bhau:

If 2S=D, then R need not be D/2 as he said. It can be anything and its value will be irrelavant.

Here's why (paraphrasing the original calcs):

Say you have two D-sided dice. On the first, D/2 sides are red and D/2 sides are blue. How many red sides must there be on die 2 for the win probability to be the same for both players?

Let R be the number of red faces on die 2. The probability of rolling two reds is (D/2)/D * R/D = R/2D. The probability of rolling two blues is (D/2)/D * (D-R)/D = (D-R)/2D. So since the probability of a win for either is 1/2,

R/2D + (D-R)/2D = 1/2

=> R + D - R = D

=> D = D

R factors out, so all values of R are correct!

And what this says is that if either die is 50/50, then no matter the configuration of the second die (provided it has only faces of either red or blue), the chances are 50/50 of getting two of the same color.

This is certainly not intuitive at first glance, but is very cool!

Joe

Roy Tock

Ranch Hand

Posts: 83

posted 13 years ago

Yup, it's clearly correct that if the first die is 50/50, then the second die can be painted in whatever manner we wish.

Kinda reminds me of a few types of proof I learned in grad school:

Proof by intimidation: Because I SAID SO!

Proof by embarrasment: Can't you see it's obvious that...

Kinda reminds me of a few types of proof I learned in grad school:

Proof by intimidation: Because I SAID SO!

Proof by embarrasment: Can't you see it's obvious that...