[Logo]
Forums Register Login
Break the loop using threads
I have a class with method calling getValues

getValues would print the values from 1 to 10

I make two objects and what gets printed is
1
2
3
...
\
..
.

1
2
3
.
..
10

What I want is

1
1
2
2
3
3
...
...
10
10



I used Threaad.sleep and also used a static variable in the class to merge the results
Now I want to know if its possible to get separately the similar values returned by each thread

1 1

2 2
Try a semaphore with one permit, look for producer / consumer examples...
thanks, that helps
 
John Vorwald wrote:Try a semaphore with one permit, look for producer / consumer examples...


Semaphore is not perfect solution to this problem. Semaphore is to guarantee that specified number of threads can only enter into restricted area but not their ordering.
Below code will work with high sleep time 100 but if you will reduce sleep from 100ms to 1ms, you can notice a difference.

output with 100 ms.
0 Thread-0
0 Thread-1
1 Thread-0
1 Thread-1
2 Thread-0
2 Thread-1
3 Thread-0
3 Thread-1
4 Thread-0
4 Thread-1
5 Thread-0
5 Thread-1
6 Thread-0
6 Thread-1
7 Thread-0
7 Thread-1
8 Thread-0
8 Thread-1
9 Thread-0
9 Thread-1
10 Thread-0
10 Thread-1
11 Thread-0
11 Thread-1
12 Thread-0
12 Thread-1
13 Thread-0
13 Thread-1
14 Thread-0
14 Thread-1
15 Thread-0
15 Thread-1
16 Thread-0
16 Thread-1
17 Thread-0
17 Thread-1
18 Thread-0
18 Thread-1
19 Thread-0
19 Thread-1

Output with 1 ms.
0 Thread-0
1 Thread-0
0 Thread-1
2 Thread-0
1 Thread-1
3 Thread-0
2 Thread-1
4 Thread-0
3 Thread-1
5 Thread-0
4 Thread-1
6 Thread-0
5 Thread-1
7 Thread-0
6 Thread-1
8 Thread-0
7 Thread-1
9 Thread-0
8 Thread-1
10 Thread-0
9 Thread-1
11 Thread-0
10 Thread-1
12 Thread-0
11 Thread-1
13 Thread-0
12 Thread-1
14 Thread-0
13 Thread-1
15 Thread-0
14 Thread-1
16 Thread-0
15 Thread-1
17 Thread-0
16 Thread-1
18 Thread-0
17 Thread-1
19 Thread-0
18 Thread-1
19 Thread-1

Cyclic Barrier is perfect solution for such problems. This is gauranteed to work with or without Thread.sleep().



output:

0 0
1 1
2 2
3 3
4 4
5 5
6 6
7 7
8 8
9 9
10 10
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
17 17
18 18
19 19
quite informative, Rohan
without semaphore, cyclic barrier, the following code produced desired result for several runs.

 
Harsha Smith wrote:without semaphore, cyclic barrier, the following code produced desired result for several runs.


This code is not perfect. Check results given below. Also what if i don;t want to put any sleep ? Above mentioned code execution is entirely based on Thread scheduler and it's not guaranteed to work always.
Try your code with just 3 threads and you will see difference.

0 Thread-0
0 Thread-1
0 Thread-2
1 Thread-0
1 Thread-1
1 Thread-2
2 Thread-0
2 Thread-1
2 Thread-2
3 Thread-0
3 Thread-1
3 Thread-2
4 Thread-0
4 Thread-1
4 Thread-2
5 Thread-0
5 Thread-1
5 Thread-2
6 Thread-0
6 Thread-1
6 Thread-2
7 Thread-0
7 Thread-1
7 Thread-2
8 Thread-0
8 Thread-1
8 Thread-2
9 Thread-0
9 Thread-1
9 Thread-2
10 Thread-0
10 Thread-1
10 Thread-2
11 Thread-0
11 Thread-1
11 Thread-2
12 Thread-0
12 Thread-1
12 Thread-2
13 Thread-0
13 Thread-1
13 Thread-2
14 Thread-0
14 Thread-1
15 Thread-0
15 Thread-1
14 Thread-2
16 Thread-0
16 Thread-1
15 Thread-2
17 Thread-0
17 Thread-1
16 Thread-2
18 Thread-0
18 Thread-1
17 Thread-2
19 Thread-0
19 Thread-1
18 Thread-2
19 Thread-2


Even with just 2 threads out put is not perfect.
Check this
0 Thread-0
0 Thread-1
1 Thread-0
1 Thread-1
2 Thread-0
2 Thread-1
3 Thread-0
3 Thread-1
4 Thread-0
4 Thread-1
5 Thread-0
5 Thread-1
6 Thread-0
6 Thread-1
7 Thread-0
7 Thread-1
8 Thread-0
8 Thread-1
9 Thread-0
9 Thread-1
10 Thread-0
10 Thread-1
11 Thread-0
11 Thread-1
12 Thread-0
12 Thread-1
13 Thread-0
14 Thread-0
13 Thread-1
15 Thread-0
14 Thread-1
16 Thread-0
15 Thread-1
17 Thread-0
16 Thread-1
18 Thread-0
17 Thread-1
19 Thread-0
18 Thread-1
19 Thread-1

Wink, wink, nudge, nudge, say no more ... https://richsoil.com/cards



All times above are in ranch (not your local) time.
The current ranch time is
Oct 19, 2017 18:03:24.